OpenAI’s crackup is another black eye for effective altruism

The parallel is just a funny coincidence (though not so funny for investors in Altman’s OpenAI, who stand to lose billions after its founder was deposed in a shocking coup on Friday afternoon). And, of course, Altman still holds a godlike status in the tech world while Bankman-Fried awaits a decades-long prison sentence for defrauding clients of his FTX crypto exchange.

Even though the two Sams are wildly different, there’s a notable overlap between the companies they founded: a link to effective altruism, the controversial philanthropic movement that espouses saving humanity through a radical form of utilitarianism. In the case of FTX, Bankman-Fried and his cronies professed devotion to “EA,” but all their high-minded words turned out to be flimflam to justify robbing people. In the case of OpenAI, the situation is more complicated.

For better or worse, the EA crowd has been one of the loudest advocates for putting guardrails on artificial intelligence. Their influence extends to OpenAI, where “at least two of the board members, Tasha McCauley and Helen Toner, have ties” to the movement. Meanwhile, it’s not clear if OpenAI cofounder Ilya Sutskever (who reportedly led the coup to depose Altman) is officially in the effective altruism camp—though he certainly seems to have a penchant for cult-like behavior.

“Anticipating the arrival of this all-powerful technology, Sutskever began to behave like a spiritual leader,” reports The Atlantic. “His constant, enthusiastic refrain was ‘feel the AGI,’ a reference to the idea that the company was on the cusp of its ultimate goal. At OpenAI’s 2022 holiday party, held at the California Academy of Sciences, Sutskever led employees in a chant: ‘Feel the AGI! Feel the AGI!’” 

The publication adds that Sutskever “commissioned a wooden effigy from a local artist that was intended to represent an ‘unaligned’ AI—that is, one that does not meet a human’s objectives. He set it on fire to symbolize OpenAI’s commitment to its founding principles.” Let’s just note, for comparison, that in all my time at Fortune I’ve never seen our CEO, Alan Murray, lead a chant or set an effigy on fire.

It’s hard to know for sure how much effective altruism did or did not contribute to OpenAI’s meltdown, but some are already pointing fingers. This includes tech writer James Ball whose critique of the company’s unworkable management structure begins with a heading “It all starts with effective altruism,” as well as Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong who railed, “If this is really some EA, decel, AI safety coup at OpenAI, the board just torched $80B of value, destroyed a shining star of American capitalism, and will be sued to high heaven by investors.”

The full story of what went down at OpenAi is complicated, and new developments are unfolding by the hour as the company appoints a new CEO and Microsoft maneuvers behind the scenes, but it seems a safe bet this latest debacle will make effective altruism even less popular than it is already.

Jeff John Roberts
[email protected]
@jeffjohnroberts

DECENTRALIZED NEWS

The price of Worldcoin—the token associated with Sam Altman's iris-scanning project—dropped on reports of his ouster from OpenAI. (The Block)

A global standards-setting body for securities regulators refused to adopt a bespoke regime for stablecoins, but proposed greater oversight of influencers. (CoinDesk)

Mastercard's CipherTrace unit announced a new integration with AI-based fraud detection service Feedzai as part of a broader push to monitor crypto exchanges. (CNBC) 

Fidelity is the latest TradFi giant to file an application for an Ethereum ETF. (CoinDesk)

Claims held by FTX's largest creditors are trading as high as 65 cents on the dollar as the company's position continues to improve in bankruptcy. (The Block)

MEME O’ THE MOMENT

Sam Altman on his guest pass: